Work Text:
The air in the Shattered Wonderland Arena hung thick with ozone and the metallic tang of dried blood. Twisted steel girders, skeletal remains of roller coasters, and the faded, peeling paint of what were once cheerful carnival rides formed the grim backdrop. Above, giant, flickering holographic screens displayed the two combatants, their images casting long, distorted shadows across the desolate ground.
"Ladies, gentlemen, and sentient beings from across the multiverse!" boomed the disembodied voice of the Announcer, reverberating through hidden speakers. "Welcome back to the Inter-Dimensional Death Match Tournament! For our this bout, we have a truly… unique pairing!"
The spotlight, a harsh white beam, snapped to the first figure. Henry Alden, tall for his age, perhaps sixteen now, stood with a determined yet weary expression. His usually neat brown hair was mussed, and his practical, albeit slightly tattered, blue shirt and jeans looked out of place against the arena's brutality. His eyes, usually bright with curiosity and resourcefulness, were now shadowed with a deep, unsettling resolve. He carried nothing but the weight of his family’s survival.
"From the quaint, rustic world of the Boxcar Children, a young man who has faced countless mysteries, outsmarted various villains, and built a home from scratch!" the Announcer roared. "He is the Architect of Ingenuity, the Quiet Strategist, HENRY ALDEN!"
A smattering of clicks and whirs, the automated applause of the Arena, filled the brief silence. Henry didn't react, his gaze scanning the vast, dangerous landscape around him, seeking cover, potential tools, an exit – anything.
The light shifted, settling on his opponent. Buddy the Elf, towering and clad in his familiar green tunic, yellow tights, and pointed hat, stood beaming, clutching a half-eaten candy cane. His innocent blue eyes took in the arena with wide, childlike wonder, completely oblivious to the inherent danger.
"And facing him, from the North Pole’s magical workshop to the bustling streets of New York, a creature of boundless joy and… surprising physical prowess!" the Announcer continued, a hint of something resembling amusement in his tone. "He is the Spirit of Christmas, the Champion of Cheer, BUDDY THE ELF!"
Buddy waved enthusiastically at the flickering screens, then peered into the cavernous darkness. "Wow! Is this like a super-sized Santa's Village? It's really… industrial! Are we making toys now? Because I'm great at making toys! As long as they're not too complicated."
Henry flinched. He had watched enough matches to know there was no talking his way out of this. The rules were absolute: one must die for the other to live. And killing Buddy… the thought twisted his gut. Buddy was pure, unadulterated innocence. But Henry had witnessed what Buddy could do, a strength born of pure, unthinking enthusiasm that could shatter steel. He had to assume Buddy, in his naivete, would not realize the consequences of his actions until it was too late. Henry had to survive. For Violet, for Jessie, for Benny. They were depending on him.
"Combatants," the Announcer’s voice deepened, losing its levity. "The match begins in… three… two… one… FIGHT!"
A harsh alarm blared, echoing off the twisted metal. Buddy’s smile widened. "Fight? Oh, like a snowball fight? Or a pillow fight? I'm good at those!" He reached down, scooped up a handful of what looked like discarded wires and rusted bolts, and compacted them into a surprisingly solid sphere. "Here! Catch!"
He launched the make-shift projectile with incredible force. It whistled through the air, heading straight for Henry's head. Henry, instincts honed by a lifetime of close calls, ducked an instant before it could connect. The metal-laced "snowball" shattered against a concrete pillar behind him, leaving a deep crater.
Henry’s eyes widened. This wasn't a game. This was a force of nature he was up against. He scrambled for cover behind a toppled concession stand, his mind racing. Brute strength was useless. He needed to outsmart Buddy.
"Oh! You're really fast!" Buddy called out, genuinely impressed. "Are we playing hide-and-seek now? I love hide-and-seek! Ready or not, here I come!"
Buddy began to stride forward, his heavy elf boots thudding on the cracked pavement. He hummed a cheerful Christmas carol, his head swiveling, eyes scanning the debris. Henry knew he couldn't hide forever. Buddy’s enthusiasm would eventually lead him to every corner.
He spotted a winding, disused service tunnel, partially collapsed but still passable. It led deeper into the labyrinthine heart of the arena, into areas filled with broken machinery and dark, cramped spaces. A plan began to form, sickening in its necessity, but a plan nonetheless.
"Over here, Buddy!" Henry shouted, making himself briefly visible before ducking into the tunnel.
"Ooh, a tunnel! Like in that movie, 'The Great Escape'!" Buddy bounded towards it, his steps surprisingly light despite his size.
Henry moved quickly, his small stature an advantage in the tightening space. He could hear Buddy’s excited hum echoing behind him, growing closer. He knew a direct confrontation was suicide. He needed to use the environment, Buddy’s strengths, and his overwhelming naivete against him.
He reached a junction where a massive, rusted gear, part of an old clockwork ride, hung precariously from a single, groaning chain. Below it, the ground was a tangled mess of broken wires and jagged metal. Henry saw his opportunity.
He grabbed a loose, heavy pipe and began to strike a nearby metal support beam, creating a rhythmic clang. "Buddy! Over here! Look what I found! It's super shiny!"
Buddy’s humming stopped. "Shiny? Like Christmas lights? Where is it?" His booming voice filled the enclosed space.
Henry continued to bang the pipe, moving towards the hanging gear. "Just a little further! It's a surprise!"
Buddy rounded the corner. His eyes immediately fixed on the glinting metal of the massive gear. But more than that, his gaze was drawn to a small, flickering light Henry had managed to activate on a broken control panel nearby – a single, pathetic red light bulb, blinking erratically.
"Oh! A Christmas light! It's not green or red, but it's still Christmas! This is the best hiding spot ever!" Buddy exclaimed, his face lighting up with genuine joy. He bounded towards the flickering light, oblivious to the unstable gear above him.
Henry’s heart pounded. He hated this. He hated himself for what he was about to do. But he saw the faces of Benny, Jessie, and Violet, cold and hungry in the boxcar, depending on him.
As Buddy reached the light, reaching out to touch it with a childish wonder, Henry lifted the pipe high. Not to strike Buddy directly, but to sever the last, corroded link holding the colossal gear in place. With a desperate cry that caught in his throat, Henry brought the pipe down with all his might.
The ancient chain shrieked in protest, then snapped with a deafening CRACK.
Buddy, his back to Henry, was still gazing at the flickering light. "Oh, happy Christmas!" he murmured, just as the massive gear plummeted.
There was a sickening, grinding crash as the multi-ton mechanism slammed down. Not directly on Buddy, but trapping him against a reinforced wall, pinning him completely. The impact echoed through the arena, followed by a terrifying stillness.
Henry stood frozen, the pipe falling from his numb fingers. He stared, wide-eyed, at the crumpled form. Buddy was unmoving, half-buried under the gear, one arm outstretched as if still reaching for the light. A faint, almost imperceptible whisper escaped him, "…syrup…"
Then, silence. Complete, utter silence.
Henry felt a wave of nausea wash over him. His knees buckled, and he collapsed to the grimy floor, burying his face in his hands. He had done it. He had won. But the victory felt like a crushing defeat. The innocent optimism, the pure joy, the boundless cheer – he had snuffed it out. He had killed Christmas.
The Announcer's voice, devoid of its earlier enthusiasm, broke the silence, cold and clinical. "And there it is. A decisive victory for… Henry Alden."
No applause this time. Just the distant hum of the arena, and the soft, almost imperceptible sound of a broken young man weeping in the darkness. Henry Alden had survived. But he knew, with a chilling certainty, that he would never truly be the same again. The weight of this match, of Buddy’s innocent last words, would follow him long after the tournament was over.