1 - 20 of 72 Works in Reader is a Proxy (Slender Man Mythos)
Navigation
Listing Works
-
Tags
Summary
You woke up due to insomnia hitting you again, walking downstairs to distract yourself, you were nearing confession soon but you found him and you accidentally did, and things took a turn..
- Language:
- English
- Words:
- 1,166
- Chapters:
- 1/1
- Kudos:
- 3
- Hits:
- 26
-
Tags
Summary
What happens when two proxies that absolutely despise each other get assigned on the same mission?
-
In the Spaces Between (Ticci Toby x male!reader) by robynlovyn
Fandoms: Creepypasta - Fandom
05 Mar 2026
Tags
Summary
Toby's tics are worse tonight. Something about the last mission, something about the way you almost didn't come back. You're the only person who knows how to calm him down—the only person he lets close enough to try. In the quiet of your shared room, vulnerability turns into something else entirely.
-
Mine— and Everyone’s gonna know it! (Ticci Toby x male!reader) by robynlovyn
Fandoms: Creepypasta - Fandom
04 Mar 2026
Tags
Summary
Jeff knows exactly what he's doing when he flirts with you in the kitchen. He knows Toby is obsessed. He knows Toby is possessive. He's doing it specifically to watch Toby lose his shit. It works. Toby reminds you—and everyone in the mansion—exactly who you belong to.
-
Creepypasta Smut One Shots by The_Dream_Eater
Fandoms: Creepypasta - Fandom, Marble Hornets
04 Mar 2026
Tags
Summary
First post on AO3 so I’m still learning tags and stuff, but this is more of a practice/passion project for me. I’m also new to writing smut so please enjoy and let me know any tips!
This is more fanon based and is in the Slendermasion AU, but I did try to keep all characters true to their original self.
I am open to requests! Just let me know.
-
Tags
Summary
Her. It's Always been her.
Your relationship with Tobias had started off friendly. Nice. Sweet. Full of laughter and fun, despite the brutal way you were brought into proxy life. For those few months, you had made the mistake of becoming attached to him. All those patrols, those outings and missions where you faced danger. Where you had each other's backs. You had laboured under the illusion that you were friends. Partners. A small part of you had hoped for more. That maybe he had felt it too.
You watched him bind the wound with clean gauze, Tobias pulled out a silly string of coloured plasters. He whistled. Clicked his tongue. He picked one with a derping dog, the eyes looking in opposite directions. He used it to secure the bandage, over the knot.
'Why do you have those silly things?' You laughed, as he stuffed them back into his pocket. He cocked his head, looking up at you from his half-kneeling position. His smile was distractingly bright.
'A silly dog sticker for my silly brave girl'
But then Natalie....Clockwork came back. And you had realised you were little more than a placeholder.
None of it was real. Not to him. At least that's what you thought.
-
Tags
Summary
A girl named Glitch who lost her way just to gain it back when she became a proxy to slenderman.
Tw: this is Creepypasta so expect triggering warnings of Sa and Sh so if your triggered by that do not eat this book. Also when you read Glitch speaking in the beginning if you know Arcane then imagine Jinx's voice.
-
Tags
Summary
To know the worth of every life but your own can feel suffocating. After Y/N attempts to take her own life, she suddenly finds herself surrounded by other people just like her, tasked with keeping them compliant & happy by an eldritch being that acts more like a father than a monster. Does she listen & act as a therapist for these troubled souls? Or does she run off, and have fate bury its hands into her no-longer beating heart?
(This is my first ever time writing, so there will be lots of mistakes)
-
May you sleep then, on some tender girlfriend's breast. by Letechi_Meesh
Fandoms: Creepypasta - Fandom
22 Feb 2026
Tags
Summary
["You're too gentle." She grunts, making you chuckle.
"That's the point..." You kiss her, still fairly gentle when you bite her lower lip. Your hand also moves, your thumb drawing hearts on her inner thigh. ]
-
Being a proxy has never been easy, neither is having a longtime crush on your close friend. However, once your boss calls you out in front of said crush, maybe it's time you make a move on her, lest you embarrass yourself even further.
A self care day between the two of you sounds nice, doesn't it? It could lead to a potential kiss... or more than that? -
Ubi amor, ibi dolor (Where there is love, there is pain) by Letechi_Meesh
Fandoms: Creepypasta - Fandom
10 Jan 2026
Tags
Summary
[Pressing your lips to his, cradling his face, the world is silent for a moment.
He's not a proxy, not Hoodie. He's Brian Thomas.
And most importantly, he's yours.]
-
Post-mission, beaten up and exhausted, you and Hoodie silently drive back to the mansion, needing to stop by the gas station for fuel and snacks. On the way to there, you stop by an abandoned playground, using the chance to distract yourselves from the proxy life for a moment by playing around and sharing a sweet kiss.
Later on, the domestic moment waivers as Hoodie is reminded of his past life by chance, throwing him into a spiral episode that he chooses to face alone.
You let him, knowing he is strong enough and by morning your boyfriend is calm again. Driving through the snow covered road, the radio plays a song you reminisce to about the early stages of you and Hoodie's relationship. -
Tags
Summary
A sudden downpour separates you and Manato from the rest of your ragtag team in the mountains of Timesworn Hills, and the two of you are forced to seek out shelter together. Little could you have known the lengths he would go in order to keep you warm.
-
Tags
Summary
Reader is having a rough time handling a particularly bad flare-up, and Tim begrudgingly offers his assistance.
Can be seen as platonic or romantic, reader has chronic anemia or similar ailments
-
Tags
Summary
You were abandoned by the Proxy whom you thought of as family, and tried to live a relatively normal life. Four years go by of this mundane living - you work, you eat, you listen to music, and you try to do self discovery meditations - when the life you thought left you behind comes barreling back at you. Your contract is unfinished, your absence was unplanned, you can’t fully be rid of the Slenderman’s influence.
(First Creepypasta Fanfiction in over six years, bare with me now) -
Tags
Summary
Dr. Y/n L/n, is a senior behavioral analyst at an oddity collections foundation, who thought she’d seen the worst humanity could cage. That was before they reassigned her entire research docket to one subject, an entity known as the Slenderman.
He doesn’t speak. Not out loud. Not until she’s alone.
What begins as standard observation, a job she rethinks every day, quickly unravels into a battle of intellect, instinct, and control. When a containment error traps her inside his enclosure, Y/n finds
herself in an impossible situation with an equally impossible solution. -
Nothing Good Starts in a Getaway Car by your_friendly_neighborhood_fictophiliac
Fandoms: Creepypasta - Fandom, Marble Hornets
08 Dec 2025
Tags
Summary
The air smells of hot Cheetos, death, and regret. But you can't stop and take it in for too long though. You have to keep moving, lest your serial-killer ex or demon ex-boss catch wind of your trail.
You'd grown complacent to the life of a proxy. That was until that pregnancy test you took for shits and gigs stared back at you with two lines. Vowing to never put a child through that Hell and Misery, destined for the life of a proxy, you do the only thing you know to do: haul ass outta there. But the Operator doesn't like giving up its murder puppets up so easily, however and your ex has a history of tracking you in his sleep.
The mix of Slender Sickness and Morning Sickness sure make for one hell of a roadtrip. The smell of your hitchhiker in the trunk doesn't help things either. That's Steve. He's just sleeping. Don't worry about him.
After all... you got other things to worry about.
-
The Past Is Right Behind You by Raine_Drops
Fandoms: Marble Hornets, Slender Man Mythos, Creepypasta - Fandom
03 Dec 2025
Tags
Summary
Tim runs away after the end of Marble Hornets and ends up in Colorado
Brian is alive after being revived by the Operator, and starts searching for Tim, where he finds Toby and eventually the Reader
Unfortunately, you can't run from fate. And running from your past works just as well, though that never stops anyone does it?Series
- Part 1 of Slenderverse Murder Trio
-
Tags
Summary
when life got tough, you turned to murder. luckily for you, you got picked up by the proxys. only problem? the boys have it out for you, and you have the hots for kate. she definitely knows, but is she only saying nothing because she feels the same or because she feels... nothing?
THERE IS NO RAPE OR SMUT!! just almost rape.
-
Tags
Summary
“Are you choosing to be a brat now just to get back at me?” You shrugged your shoulders at Tim’s question, watching as he twisted the gun in your mouth to press up against the roof of it. “What’s stopping me from blowing your brains out right here, right now?”
In the middle of a mission, Tim has had enough of you testing his patience. He has a gun, you don't.
OR
Kinktober day 23 - Gun play
Series
- Part 22 of Roseyful's Kinktober 2025
-
Ticci Toby x Reader comfort oneshot <33 by HeavenLovesCupcakez
Fandoms: Creepypasta - Fandom
05 Nov 2025
Tags
Summary
You´re in your room crying, hoping for some type of comfort....Toby comes along.
-
Dont treat burns with lukewarm water by creepypancakes
Fandoms: Creepypasta - Fandom, Marble Hornets
02 Nov 2025
Tags
Summary
wake up. ignore it. go to school. come home. sleep.
this is your routine. this has been been your routine for years. the routine in your mostly mundane life that has kept you sane.
But when the pot boils over, you’ll get burned trying to grab it off the stove. But in your case what else are you supposed to do? let it sizzle over and spill onto the floor?
things are changing, and your bound to panic.
especially when your life slowly progresses to a turning point that you wont be able to undo.
How do you deal with the molten pot of your hallucinations becoming more and more real, when you get caught in the middle of a missings persons case?-