Gifts for MothballMilkshake
List of Gifts
-
Tags
Summary
Had Alastor been told that he'd wind up in a relationship with the mother-ducking King of Hell, he would have laughed in their face and delivered a barrage of insults towards their limited realm of knowledge. And yet, following the events of Vox's attempted takeover of Hell and Heaven, Alastor finds himself in such a relationship.
Had Alastor been told that he'd one day pose nude for a painting done by none other than the King of Hell, he likely would have ripped them to shreds and consumed every part of them for thinking such a thing. And yet, after a precarious deal for his own interest, Alastor finds himself in such a situation.
Had Alastor been told that his sensitive secrets would be announced to the populace of Hell, he might have avoided getting involved with the King of Hell. And yet...
___
aka
A story of a budding romance, an accidental betrayal, and the consequences that follow. -
Avoiding isn’t the answer. by bpbabe for MothballMilkshake
Fandoms: Hazbin Hotel (Cartoon)
15 Feb 2026
Tags
-
Plan A: Tell everyone Alastor tops. Plan B: ...whatever this is. by PuffinStack for MothballMilkshake
Fandoms: Hazbin Hotel (Cartoon)
15 Feb 2026
Tags
Summary
"He could claim it was all a joke, an error, a misunderstanding—but in Hell, no one cared about correcting misinformation. No matter what, this story was out, and it would spread fast, considering the reach of Alastor’s broadcast and the fact that Vox listened to it obsessively. There was nothing he could do.
Lucifer wished his magic could turn back time. Could take the words 'Come on down to bed, Al,' out of everyone’s minds and pull the sound back through the radio waves into his big, stupid mouth."
Or, all of Hell heard Lucifer call Alastor down to bed. What's a devil to do to fix his mistake? Well, apparently...whatever this is. (Alastor vetoed Plan A.)
[Written for MothballMilkshake's 500 Mothballs WTIYS! Congratulations, Moth!!]
-
Hell's Greatest Bachelor by pumpkabae for MothballMilkshake
Fandoms: Hazbin Hotel (Cartoon)
14 Feb 2026
Tags
Summary
For MothballMilkshake's 500 Followers DTIYS/WTIYS!
Marrying Alastor to Lilith was not on Lucifer's list of things to do today. Making himself Hell's most eligible bachelor wasn't either.
-
Come one (nearly) live on air! by Artemis_07 for MothballMilkshake
Fandoms: Hazbin Hotel (Cartoon)
13 Feb 2026
Tags
Summary
Alastor and Lucifer were just supposed to be talking on his radio show, of course they had to go and get frisky! Now it's up to Lucifer to try and salvage what he can of Alastor's dignity.
.
.
.
For Moth's 500 dtiys on bluesky!Series
- Part 6 of DTIYS’s
-
Tags
Summary
The origin story of Alastor's wheelie chair. Some assembly required.
A gift for Moth, because certain things are taking a while to organise.
-
70 Minutes in Heaven by PhoenixArising for MothballMilkshake
Fandoms: Hazbin Hotel (Cartoon)
28 Dec 2025
Tags
Summary
Sir Pentious isn't allowed to leave Heaven, even though the angels are allowed to go down to hell and make a mess of things. Sure, sending letters up to him is nice, but this isn't 1812, and Cherri Bomb is sick of waiting three to five angelic business days for a reply. They've left her no choice. If Sir Pentious can't come visit her, Cherri will simply have to break into Heaven instead. Vox was planning on doing it, how hard can it be?
-
Do you come from a land down under where women glow and men plunder? by Arthyradio for MothballMilkshake
Fandoms: Hazbin Hotel (Cartoon)
05 Jul 2025
Tags
Summary
The battle’s over. The hotel’s (mostly) intact. And Cherri Bomb’s moved in, bringing goon, and enough rural Aussie slang to melt Husk's last brain cell. No one's sure if she’s a threat or a pub brawl given form, but they're pretty sure she’s family now.
A no-plot, all-vibes one-shot featuring goon sacks, chicken parmi, slang, and a deadset legend.
-
Love Me Like You Do by PuffinStack for MothballMilkshake
Fandoms: Hazbin Hotel (Cartoon)
27 Jun 2025
Tags
Summary
"Alastor’s ear twitched as Vox shifted his wrists against each other in his lap, the cables looped around them creaking as their plastic coatings rubbed against each other.
This was their compromise."
or, my take on some radiostatic smut as inspired by Signals Lost and Found. Takes place after Part 30 (Music to my Nervous System) and before Part 47 (Get Lost in the Pain).
-
Unrestrained Devotion by PhoenixArising for MothballMilkshake
Fandoms: Hazbin Hotel (Cartoon)
29 Dec 2024
Tags
Summary
“How do you forget about someone in the middle of sex?” Mimzy squawked.
“He’s very distractible, and we weren’t in the middle of sex, technically.”Lucifer ties Alastor up, it doesn't go according to plan.
-
A circus full of beasties by Godlizza for MothballMilkshake
Fandoms: Hazbin Hotel (Cartoon)
28 Dec 2024
Tags
Summary
“Alastor. Is there something you want to share with us?” she asked.
Alastor’s gaze instantly took on a cagey look, his ears dipping slightly. “Why, whatever do you mean?”
“I mean,” Vaggie bit out, “it looks an awful lot like you have fleas too.”
~*~
Angel brings home some unwanted guests after filming with a mangy co-star, leading to all the furry hotel residents catching fleas, including Alastor. Most men fear death, but Alastor only fears The Comb.