Actions

Work Header

At Sea in the Middle of Ithilien

Summary:

Legolas' Sea-longing through the eyes of his lover, long after he became afflicted. This is the story of all the ways it pulls them apart and brings them together, bound as they are to Arda and to their friends' mortal lives. Rifts are deepened, insecurities revisited, and mysteries abound as worst fears are realized--at sea in the middle of Ithilien.

Part one of "Fighting the Tide" series.

Notes:

Originally written on a whim and posted in September 2017 on another site. Original authors' notes will be included at the beginning of each chapter, as necessary. Much thanks to Cheekybeak for beta-reading parts of this all those years ago now! UnnamedElement wouldn't have got far without Cheekybeak (lol).

Some good notes for considering as you read this are enumerated at the end of this chapter, but please skip them if this block of text is overwhelming! You readers are smart and you can figure it out. :)

Chapter 1

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

Ithilien, Fourth Age 30

I have been in love with Legolas for a long time. I did not know it for centuries—though not as long as he denied it—not until after we had already served as captains together for too long to turn away from our duties. I have loved others—though not been in love with them—and I have seen others here and there, and Legolas knows this. He has seen no one else—his interest in romance is stunted, and he has a lot of growing yet to do—but he is constantly falling in and out of love with me.

I do not mind that anymore, because he always circles back, as he does in all things. Not many know it, but there is a steadiness to his caprice, and a predictability.

I am good for him. He needs an anchor, and I sometimes need a catalyst.

It seems Gimli and I serve much the same purpose, these days.

Legolas spends much time with him, and if I did not feel badly for how soon Gimli will have to leave this world I might resent him that, but I do feel badly for him—and he keeps Legolas more whole in the moments he is with me, besides—so I do not resent him at all. Saida tells me that the first time the Sea-longing took Legolas badly in Ithilien—several years since I had last seen him, at that point—that Gimli is who brought him back to us. Alfirinion—Saida's nephew—kept him here, but Gimli... He brought him back.

Legolas does love children. I knew Legolas when he was an older brother but, for longer years, I have know him as the youngest. Losing his sister changed him, and I think that is why he is so good with children. They slow him down so that the world moves more slowly, and he can look around and see what is about without spinning off. Do not get me wrong—Legolas can be patient and measured, but when he has no need to be... He is anything but.

Not being able to give Legolas children is my only regret, and it is the only thing he, too, cannot give me—everything else in this love we work around, but that is an emptiness, I think.

I joked once that he should marry Saida if she would be willing to give him children. I remember how he laughed and laughed; head thrown back, it rocked his hips until he fell flat on his back and I lost him in the stars. When I crawled on top of him, I saw them reflected in the dark grey of his eyes, and then he focused and smiled again, took my head between his hands and whispered: "Never." He rolled me over and made me look at the stars instead, and he proceeded to show me all the ways he could never ever be with Saida.

She is too much a sister to either of us, besides. And she has taken care of Legolas too much to be his lover.

But Legolas is not well, right now. His thoughts are away more often than not, and he has signed over governance of Ithilien temporarily. He is a memory of himself—or he is himself most embodied? I have not quite yet figured out what the Sea does to him.

We do not make love when he is like this, even when he wants it, because—to me—it is like he is not here.

It burns my heart.

...I asked Aragorn, once, what Legolas was like when he first heard the gulls, but Aragorn was not there with him, and so he does not know. I asked Gimli, too, but that is a sore subject, it seems, for Legolas did not tell Gimli about the Sea for weeks, and so Gimli felt he had left Legolas all that time unprotected. Finally, I asked Legolas what it was like—I asked him how it might have looked to other people so that I would know, but he told me he did not know, because he was not other people.

I could have smacked him for that cheek (and I did, in fact, cuff him).

Once, Legolas left—as he will sometimes do—and we could not find him, at all. He showed back up—a month later!—with Gimli. He had traveled to the Glittering Caves and then ridden back. He could not remember a quarter of his journey—because it was all colors, Ithildim!—and his arm was broken. He stayed with Saida for a week, then, because I could not look at him without wanting to scream, and Legolas is not well-affected by yelling. He will simply stare at you, until you are left breathless, and then he bursts into laughter. If he were not so kind I would sometimes think him soulless, the way he sometimes laughs, so unexpectedly, and inappropriately.

But he is kind, nevertheless, and I love him.

Still, I am at a loss now.

It is quiet in this house when he disappears.

Notes:

Potentially helpful notes:

 
1. Almost all my stories are interconnected, even the incomplete/WIP ones (posted on ff.net at this point in time). Many are referenced in this piece, but it is not necessary to have read them to enjoy this, though you will certainly understand my Legolas' characterization and my OCs better if you have read them. That being said, they are not necessary to understand the story and, when they are, I will note it in chapter notes. Relevant things about characters are outlined briefly in the rest of these numbers.

2. Ithildim, Saida, and Legolas grew up together, and have experienced quite a lot of good and bad things along the way. They have endured well and grown through it, but they each carry scars of their own kind, and they are each generally aware of these, even when they aren't visible. Ithildim and Legolas served together in the King's Army, and Saida was a scout, instructor, and all-around "renaissance lady" when it came to the army's needs. Also, Lumornon--who is mentioned later--is Legolas' older brother, and their relationship is the most immovable and consistent one he has with his remaining family (which started at 6 members but has since shrunk to 3).

3. Ithildim and Legolas have been involved with one another on and off for years, but have skirted around making a formal/public commitment due to their roles in Mirkwood and each other's perceived inability of the other to navigate the complexities that would entail which, thus, also makes their relationship frustratingly on-again-off-again. Ithilien, therefore, is the first time they have ever allowed themselves to recognize their love for what it really is, and to give it a chance. It's honestly all a bit tragic, really.

4. A note on culture and ethnicity: Ithildim is Silvan, and his mother also has Avarin ancestors. Saida is entirely Silvan, though also a smidgen Danian/laegrim (the Silvan who crossed the mountains at the end of Year of the Trees, some of whom ended up living and interacting with Sindar in Doriath). In this way, Saida and Legolas are *very* distantly related, as I write Oropher's wife as being green-elf. (And they are also related through Legolas' mother, but with a difference of a few of generations and several times removed--that's neither here nor there, though.) In my universe, Legolas' mother is Silvan, so he is a quarter Sindarin, half straight-up Mirkwood woodelf/Silvan, and a quarter old-school laegrim. This is relevant because I write Eldarin elves (Sindar, Noldor, etc) as being more affected by and prone to the Sealonging than wood-elves generally. Elven diaspora is something else...

5. At this point, via events in Enough (a fic on ff.net that is almost to its end, and I will be posting it here soon), Legolas' mother has already sailed, years and years ago now, and her reasons for sailing were...distinctly unpleasant. There is therefore some unresolved family trauma at play here, though that is more relevant to the sequel ("Strange Comforts"). During the events of Enough, Legolas became very close with Ithildim's family, which is where his tendency toward baking comes from (Ithildim's mother is a baker; his father a healer; LACE opposites, I know).

6. Alfirinion and Ewessel are Saida's nephew and niece who were effectively orphaned during the Battle Under the Trees. They grew up mostly under Saida and Legolas in Ithilien, as she joined him there immediately but Ithildim waited until about Fourth Age 5 to immigrate.

7. Elboron is Faramir and Eowyn's child. Elboron maybe has a son, Barahir, at some point, but it is unclear and, besides, this child is not the one involved in this story, anyway.

8. Sponsors are basically godparents in certain traditions—I have no idea about Gondorian child-rearing. I have made everything having to do with that up.