Actions

Work Header

Rating:
Archive Warning:
Category:
Fandoms:
Relationships:
Characters:
Additional Tags:
Language:
English
Series:
Part 3 of This Ain't Odysseus's Odyssey - My PJO Fics
Stats:
Published:
2026-02-01
Updated:
2026-02-15
Words:
11,388
Chapters:
3/17
Comments:
47
Kudos:
153
Bookmarks:
50
Hits:
1,791

One Life, Then Another

Summary:

The Olympians vote to kill Percy at the Winter Solstice, long before he has the chance to turn sixteen. But the war still needs a prophecy child. The Titans have stolen the Sword of Hades, and they bring Percy back to offer him a deal: if he fights for them, he’ll get his revenge.

Unfortunately, Percy Jackson has never done what anyone expected of him.

Notes:

So. I wrote this - all 80k of it - in less than three weeks. That's what being obsessed and unemployed is for!

I'm posting the first chapter today because a) I finished it on Thursday and didn't want to wait any longer and b) it's the first day of Febuwhump! While this fic was already in the slow cooker when I saw the prompts, the fact that one of the alt prompts was "Lazarus" helped me to kickstart one of my many ideas of someone coming back from the dead in the PJO universe.

All the chapters are pre-written, so I'll update every Sunday! I need the time to edit, because the plot changed a fair bit as I wrote it - right up until I wrote the actual resurrection scene, the plan was to use the Doors of Death to bring him back, not the Sword of Hades, for example - and also just because pre-writing everything is the only way I can stick to an update schedule. This chapter is more a prologue than a chapter, so it's short and sweet, but the others will be meatier.

An alternative title for this was Once Smitten, Twice Shy, but unfortunately I realised that the past tense of smite is smote. Then I was gonna call it Just One Life or One Life To Take after the song Survive from Epic: The Musical, but the spirit of that song and in killing the one life doesn't really fit the theme of this fic... But I still liked the One Life theme, so I just tweaked it a bit. Plausible deniability for my Epic reference.

A couple of other housekeeping notes:
- I've only tagged characters who either a) appear in multiple chapters or b) have a significant character moment within the longfic or a significant impact on Percy (or both). Other characters do appear, but I didn't want to clutter their tag with a longfic that barely features them.
- Similarly, I only tagged the relationships that most significantly impact the plot/character arcs of the fic, e.g. I tagged Paul & Percy because that's plot relevant, but while Percy & Sally is obviously instrumental to Percy's character, their relationship takes more of a backseat in the way the plot unfolds.
- I tagged Annabeth and Percy's relationship as / instead of &, even though it could go both ways. This is post-TTC, so I think they've definitely caught feelings by now, especially since absence makes the heart grow fonder, but also... it's complicated. So they don't do anything overtly romantic in this fic but I wrote it with the intention that they have romantic feelings for each other they just haven't acted on yet.
- In general if you think anything about the tags should be changed, just let me know!

I think that's everything. Hope you enjoy!

(See the end of the work for more notes.)

Chapter 1: Athena Insults My Dad

Chapter Text

“Now for the Ophiotaurus,” Artemis said.

“This boy is still dangerous,” Dionysus warned. “The beast is a temptation to great power. Even if we spare the boy—”

“No.” Percy looked around at all the gods, his heart hammering. He hadn’t said much while they discussed his own demise, but Bessie had declared him his protector. He couldn’t let them kill him. “Please. Keep the Ophiotaurus safe. My dad can hide him under the sea somewhere, or keep him in an aquarium here in Olympus. But you have to protect him.”

“And why should we trust you?” rumbled Hephaestus.

“I’m only fourteen,” Percy said. “If this prophecy is about me, that’s two more years.”

“Two years for Kronos to deceive you,” Athena said. “Much can change in two years, my young hero.”

“Mother!”

Percy glanced at Annabeth, gratified by her outburst. A year ago, Annabeth wouldn’t have dreamt of questioning Athena.

“It is only the truth, child. It is bad strategy to keep the animal alive. Or,” Athena studied Percy intently, “the boy.”

Percy swallowed, not liking the intense look on Athena’s face. She looked like Annabeth had a long time ago, when she’d come up with a brilliant Capture the Flag strategy that put him right in Clarisse’s crosshairs. Except somehow, her calculating expression was harsher, colder. Annabeth had been there, invisible, ready to step in before the Ares kids killed him. Athena would throw him to the wolves without hesitation, if she thought it was the strategic thing to do.

And she did think that.

He was used to dealing with terrifying situations on his own, with no adult or mentor to turn to. So, it surprised him as much as anyone else when he instinctively glanced at Poseidon for reassurance. Would he let this happen?

Poseidon stood. “I will not have a sea creature destroyed if I can help it. And I can help it.”

He held out his hand, and a trident appeared in it: a six-metre-long bronze shaft with three spear tips that shimmered with blue, watery light. “I will vouch for the boy, and the safety of the Ophiotaurus.”

Percy blinked. Shock paralysed him for a moment, followed by warmth at the gesture. What did vouching for him mean? He didn’t know exactly, but by the way the gods had shifted, looking between Percy and Poseidon with renewed interest, it was serious.

But now Zeus was on his feet as well. “You won’t take it under the sea! I won’t have that kind of bargaining chip in your possession.”

“Brother, please—”

The room smelled like a storm. Zeus was holding his lightning bolt.

Poseidon met Percy’s eyes briefly—just a flash of green—before sighing. “Fine. I will build an aquarium for the creature here. Hephaestus can help me.” He nodded to the god, but Percy couldn’t read Hephaestus’s expression. His face was still fixed in a scowl. “The creature will be safe. We shall protect it with all our powers. The boy will not betray us.” He slowed his words, looking around as if to make sure they found their marks. “I vouch for this on my honour.”

Oh. So, he was vouching on his honour. Yeah, that was serious.

Zeus looked suspicious still but thoughtful. Then Athena said, “You also swore, once, that a boy like this would never exist, uncle.”

Poseidon looked like he’d swallowed a lemon. “You question me?”

“I do. The sea is changeable, as are you. The boy’s existence proves it. If he is the same,” she turned her grey eyes back on Percy, and it took all his power not to back away, “the last thing we want is a changeable prophecy child who has not yet turned sixteen.”

Artemis came to Percy’s defence. “Our father also broke the oath, Athena. If you are to question Poseidon’s honour, you must also question his.”

“And I would, were Thalia still a threat. But you have saved her from ever turning sixteen. It is unfortunate that the boy has no such recourse.”

The worst part was that when she looked over at him again, Athena did seem almost sorry for him. She glanced at Annabeth, and Percy got the feeling that she regretted every word she said, especially that she said them in front of her daughter. But she believed they were necessary points to make.

“Enough,” Zeus said. “Poseidon has vouched for the boy and the beast, on his honour. All in favour of letting them both live?”

Poseidon and Artemis raised their hands. Apollo followed his sister’s example, looking serious in a way Percy hadn’t seen him before. Aphrodite raised her hand delicately, shooting him a wink when she noticed him looking at her. Percy wasn’t sure what to think of that. Finally, Hermes and Hephaestus twitched. Hephaestus raised his hand with the slowness of a winch, his gaze on Bessie like he was already thinking up aquarium designs. But after an initial movement like he was going to raise his hand, Hermes glanced at Poseidon, glanced at Percy, and looked away. He remained still.

“All opposed?” Zeus asked, tone neutral. He raised his own hand, mirrored by Athena, Ares, and Dionysus. Hera and Demeter followed, and finally Hermes did too. He wasn’t looking at Percy anymore.

Poseidon was staring at his fellow Olympians in shock. “You doubt my word?”

“Silence, brother. The votes have been cast.” Zeus stood, his lightning bolt back in his hand. He ignored Bessie to look at Percy.

Percy remembered returning that bolt to him, less than two years ago. He had looked up at Zeus then, and he had watched his uncle’s expression soften minutely as he looked down at him, even as he still glowered. It was much the same now. Just like his daughter, Zeus pitied Percy.

But not enough to save him.

Poseidon surged to his feet. “Brother—”

There was a flash of white. Ozone billowed through the air. Every molecule of Percy’s body ignited—and he knew no more.


On the banks of the River Styx, Charon’s fleshless face grinned at him. “Finally drowned in that bathtub?”